Welcome to Sunny's Ice Cream Shop, Lake Mary's newest destination for handcrafted, premium ice cream. We proudly serve authentic Amish-style ice cream, made locally in Sarasota in small batches using traditional methods and rich, high-butterfat cream for an exceptionally smooth, creamy texture and unforgettable flavor.
 

At Sunny's, we believe great ice cream starts with quality ingredients. Most of our flavors are crafted with natural ingredients and naturally sweetened, while a few fun favorites—like Cookie Monster and Cotton Candy—feature vibrant colors for a playful twist. We also offer dairy-free and sugar-free options, so everyone can enjoy a delicious treat.
 

From timeless classics to exciting specialty flavors, every visit to Sunny's is made to bring people together over handcrafted ice cream that's rich, authentic, and made with care. We look forward to serving you and making every scoop a sweet memory.